NEWS BLOG: An Angry Blog, Part 1 – Rochester’s test scores


It’s hard to start your day angry, but that was me this morning. News from several quarters had me in a froth before I could finish breakfast.

And so, a blog in three parts:

Angry Blog 1: Yesterday this region got yet another release of really bad news: The Rochester School District had the worst test scores of any of the state’s big cities in the latest State Ed Department report .

The worst.

And, let me note, the state’s big cities have worse scores than the average district.

You know the reason that urban school districts have the worst scores: that’s where the state’s poor children are concentrated. Why did test scores in Rochester drop when those of the other Big 5 cities rose a bit?

Who cares?

Seriously. Who cares?

Next year it could be Buffalo that drops a bit, and Rochester that goes up a bit. It doesn’t matter. What matters is the long-term trend, the long-term performance. And long-term, urban school district and their children are doing really, really poorly.

According to this latest report, in Rochester, nearly 80 percent of the students in third through eighth grade didn’t meet state standards in English proficiency. Nearly 80 percent.

In math, nearly 73 percent of them didn’t meet state standards.

How are children who do that poorly in third or eighth grade going to succeed in high school? What are the chances that they’ll graduate? Get a job?

Are you angry yet?

We’d all better be. But get angry at what? At whom?

This community’s traditional reaction is: Damn the teachers. Damn the parents. Damn the school board. Damn the superintendent.

Shouldn’t we have that out of our system by now?

All those people can improve. But we’ve using that excuse for decades. And the test scores get worse and worse. And children’s lives are wasted.

Concentrated poverty is the reason. It’s not an “excuse,” as some of the district’s critics like to insist, it’s the reason.

We can address that, or we can keep looking away.

I suspect that we’ll keep looking away. It’s a pity that the only damage from that is to our own conscience.



  1. j.a.m. · · Reply

    Poverty is a symptom, not a cause. The root cause of poverty is the complete breakdown of the family owing to rampant promiscuity, bastardy and divorce, exacerbated by liberal social engineering. Nothing will change till that does.

  2. “Concentrated poverty is the reason. It’s not an “excuse,” as some of the district’s critics like to insist, it’s the reason.”

    OK Mary Anna, when I drive through most parts of the city, I don’t get the feeling that people with any kind of wealth are welcome. With unemployment in the city so high, why don’t you see people everywhere with brooms, rakes and paint brushes? Why do residents allow so much crime in their neighborhoods?

  3. Anonymous · · Reply

    Unfortunately, we are called to teach children (not all, but a majority) who are not being raised to value and respect an education. Why get an education if you don’t NEED a job? The government will take care of you like it takes care of your parents. Drop out of high school and have a baby, the government will take care of both of you. Until these children see with their own eyes what a person can achieve with a good education and a job, nothing will change.

  4. Anonymous · · Reply

    Not only will the government take care of you, RCSD will take care of you. Come to school without a pencil or a piece of paper? Here’s some. No shorts for gym? Here’s a pair. No coat? We’re having a coat drive. Walk out of the house half naked? Here’s a sweater to cover up. And on and on.

    When – when – will we stop making every excuse for parents and insist that they TOO have responsibilities to meet?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: