GOVERNMENT: IDA’s, by the numbers

Colin O’Malley. FILE PHOTO


Last year, the Monroe County Industrial Development Agency approved more projects than any other IDA in New York, says a report from the state Authorities Budget Office. But those projects have not resulted in the most private investment.

COMIDA approved 40 projects, totaling $81.7 million in private investment and approximately $1.5 million in various tax exemptions, the report says. The Niagara County IDA had 14 projects totaling $432.3 million in private investment and $4.4 million in exemptions. One of those projects is a massive $400 million paper mill, however, says an end-of-the-year slideshow from that county.

The job creation figures are trickier. COMIDA says it’s gaining 494 full-time equivalent jobs through its projects, placing it among the top IDA’s in terms of job creation. Niagara, on the other hand, expects to gain 61 full-time equivalent positions. But the Niagara County IDA also anticipates the creation of 3,400 temporary construction jobs, while COMIDA expects 330.

Colin O’Malley, organizing director with Metro Justice, says the tax breaks mean less money for school districts and local governments. So if the jobs don’t materialize or don’t pay particularly well, that raises questions about the value of the tax breaks to the community.

“There’s very little follow-up after the deals are brokered,” O’Malley says.

Metro Justice belongs to statewide coalitions that advocate for claw-back provisions, which allow IDA’s to recover tax money when companies don’t live up to their promises.

For comparison, here’s how a few other IDA’s stack up, according to the Authorities Budget Office report:

• The Amherst IDA reported investments of $119 million for five projects, approximately $672,000 in tax exemptions, and a gain of 496 full-time equivalent positions. The projects created 41 FTE construction jobs.

• The Erie County IDA reported five projects totaling approximately $20 million in private investment and $636,500 in tax exemptions. It expects an increase of 18 full-time equivalent positions and created 145 FTE construction jobs.

• The Onondaga County IDA reported four projects with $23.1 million in private investment and $325,800 in tax exemptions. It expects an increase of 40 full-time equivalent positions and created 236 FTE construction jobs.



  1. One of the biggest problems with the IDA’s is that there is little follow up on job creation. No one checks to see if the promised jobs are created and there is no penalty if they are not. If you look at the numbers IDA’s in NYS claim to have created 1.5 million jobs form 2003 -2009. Yet from 2000-2010 the number of jobs in NY remained roughly unchanged at 6 million. One of the biggest projects approved by COMIDA is the Irondequoit Mall project but nothing has been done on this and none of the promised jobs have been created! Yet the owner continues to enjoy his tax breaks. Too often this is what development through IDA’s looks like.

  2. When you are ready to end ALL types of welfare except for the 10% who are truelly needy, count me in. While you complain about a few hundred thousand dollars for business development, what about taxpayers giving Buffalo $1 BILLION DOLLARS??????

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: